When it’s your birthday, you want more than just a decent meal—you want a place that helps you celebrate with pomp and ceremony. Or maybe you want something lowkey but still special? Want to sip cocktails in Patchogue after dinner? Done. Prefer a relaxed waterfront meal in Port Jefferson or a big group table in Huntington Village? Easy. For family-style feasts with space for the whole crew, check out spots in Garden City and Smithtown. Just be sure to ask about minimums for weekend reservations—some places fill up fast. Ready to find the right fit? Scroll on to see Long Island birthday restaurants worth toasting in.